pdp1@EARTHLINK.NET on tue 27 may 03
I feel very positive about your shareing your experience of
the mugs and anything else you may care to mention. I say,
good for you. I found nothing in anyone's candor yet as I
could object to.
I am curious though, you say "I appreciate Koie's gesture
concerning 9/11. "
And...well, just what do you see that 'gesture' as having
There is a gesture there...
It may be interesting to mention or share how
it came across to various of us.
We could ask him to tell us...what he intended...or the
'thought' as may have animated the otherwise seemingly
tentative or halting incidental incorporation of it...which
be an interesting experiment to do...to 'ask'.
See what he says...
But meanwhile, what do we 'say'?
How did it come across to us?
----- Original Message -----
From: "John Horner"
Sent: Monday, May 26, 2003 4:00 AM
Subject: Re: Koie Rioji's prices and Koie .. look again ..
see .. perceive
With all the "shame on you" sentiment being posted because
some of us have stated our "PERSONAL OPINION" about Koie's
mugs, I found myself feeling a little guilty for "trashing"
an artist's work. I looked again, tried to see and perceive
these mugs in a different light. To be fair to Koie, I have
looked at lots of his work on the internet, all of the links
that Helen posted and more, and find many of his pieces that
I do like, some quite well. I have no doubt that Koie is a
brilliant and accomplished artist. I appreciate Koie's
gesture concerning 9/11. All that said.... Sorry, I still
don't care for the mugs. They are not pleasing to MY eye.
They don't summon ME to pick them up. My distaste for Koie's
mugs has very little to do with price. I wouldn't want them
for any price. Isn't it a wonderful thing that all of us
don't have the same taste. What a boring world this would
be. I am just saddened that we can't express our personal
opinions, without being accused of "trashing", "bashing",
and "defiling our own nest". I don't like the mugs, and I am
certain that Koie would understand and be OK with my
opinion. Again, thanks for the opportunity to voice my
Send postings to email@example.com
You may look at the archives for the list or change your
settings from http://www.ceramics.org/clayart/
Moderator of the list is Mel Jacobson who may be reached at