search  current discussion  categories  techniques - slips 

water versus slip

updated wed 4 mar 98

 

Israel Amirav on sun 1 mar 98

Hello everyone,

In her workshop here in Israel, Ruthanne Tudball from U.K, demonstrated how
she throws pots, using thick slip instead of water.
Can anyone shed light on this issue and explain which method is better ?

Thanks,

Naama

kinoko@junction.net on mon 2 mar 98

At 17:20 3/1/98 EST, you wrote:
>----------------------------Original message----------------------------
>Hello everyone,
>
>In her workshop here in Israel, Ruthanne Tudball from U.K, demonstrated how
>she throws pots, using thick slip instead of water.
>Can anyone shed light on this issue and explain which method is better ?
>
> Thanks,
>
>Naama, As "Candy is dandy,but liquor is quicker",Ogden Nash. So slip is
superior to water since slip is simply fine clay suspended in water.
However, in throwing large pieces of finely grogged clay,water makes its
own slip in the process of throwing. We prefer a good medium thick slip. We
have thrown clays others have averred were impossible. All a matter of what
materials one has at hand. In India,I recall that mule or horse manure is
used in the clay body because of the finely divided and undigested straw
material. All a matter of taste? Don & Isao.
>

Corinne Null on mon 2 mar 98

Sept 10, 1997 John Baymore posted the following:

Let me put in my 2 cents here for throwing using slurry, not water. Solves
a multitude of problems. Basic theory........ what happens to clay when
you add water? It gets soft and slumpy and gooshy. Less water added, less
softening of the clay. Slurry contains less water per unit of "slippery"
effect ..... keeps the clay stronger. Takes some getting used to if you
are a voluminous water user to start with. I use something about the
consistency of sour cream.
I teach students to use slurry from the start.


At 05:20 PM 3/1/98 -0500, you wrote:
>----------------------------Original message----------------------------
>Hello everyone,
>
>In her workshop here in Israel, Ruthanne Tudball from U.K, demonstrated how
>she throws pots, using thick slip instead of water.
>Can anyone shed light on this issue and explain which method is better ?
>
> Thanks,
>
>Naama
>
Corinne Null
Bedford, NH

null@mediaone.net

Jim Karavias on tue 3 mar 98

Hi Naama,

My understanding is that slip (rather than water) is less likely to
remove the finer particles from the surface of the clay as you're
throwing. Allowing the finer particles to remain in the clay body
maintains plasticity and allows for longer throwing time.

I guess If you throw quickly it matters less.

Jim

On Sunday, March 01, 1998 2:21 PM, Israel Amirav
[SMTP:amirav@canaan.co.il] wrote:
> ----------------------------Original
message----------------------------
> Hello everyone,
>
> In her workshop here in Israel, Ruthanne Tudball from U.K,
demonstrated how
> she throws pots, using thick slip instead of water.
> Can anyone shed light on this issue and explain which method is better
?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Naama